|
Edward Stone
Attorney at Law
435.658.3366 |
 |
UTAH FIELD SOBRIETY TESTING
Please select from below for applicable Utah statutes and explanations:
* This is by no means intended to be a
complete description of filed sobriety testing in the State of
Utah. This page is intended to give a litigant an idea
of analysis of field sobriety tests. A complete description
of rights can be found in the Utah Code and the Utah Rules
and the NHTSA Manual.
Do not rely on this page alone for guidance; consult with
an attorney. This page does not create an attorney-client
relationship.
Please contact Edward Stone for more information.
|
Horizontal gaze nystagmus refers
to an involuntary jerking of the eye as a suspect gazes
towards their periphery of their vision. Nystagmus
becomes readily noticeable when a person is impaired.
The greater the impairment, the sooner the eyes will
begin to involuntarily bounce as the person starts
looking toward their periphery.
The horizontal gaze nystagmus test (or
HGN), is the most reliable field sobriety test.
The test itself is administered as
follows:
(1) the officer has the subject follow a small stimulus
such as a pen, penlight, eraser on a pencil, or the tip
of the officers finger, anything that contrasts with the
background;
(2) the officer positions the stimulus 12-15 inches from
the suspect's nose and slightly above eye level;
(3) the officer is to check that both pupils are the
same size and both track together by making a pass;
(4) the HGN is to begin with the subjects left eye with
a pass to the officer's right. The officer is to
move the stimulus at a speed that requires approximately
2 seconds to bring the suspect's eye as far to the
periphery as possible;
(5) the officer is to move the stimulus all the way to
the periphery of the suspect's right eye, again taking
approximately 2 seconds out to the periphery and two
seconds back, looking for clues both out and back:
(6) the officer repeats the procedure. (this concludes
the smooth pursuit portion of the test);
(7) the officer checks for distinct nystagmus at maximum
deviation beginning with the left eye by moving the
stimulus to the edge of the periphery. No white
should be showing in the corner of the eye at maximum
deviation.;
(8) the officer is to hold the eye at that position for
no less than 4 seconds and look for nystagmus.
(9) the office moves the stimulus all the way across the
suspect's face and check the right eye, using the same
procedure;
(10) the officer repeats the procedure. (this concludes
the nystagmus at maximum deviation portion of the HGN);
(11) the officer now checks for onset of nystagmus prior
to 45 degrees. The officer begins with the
suspect's left eye.
(12) The officer moves the stimulus at a speed that
would take approximately 4 seconds for the stimulus to
reach the edge of the suspect's shoulder;
(13) when the officer observes nystagmus, he is to hold
in the position and verify the nystagmus:
(14) the officer notes the angle of onset of nystagmus:
(15) the officer repeats the procedure:
(16)
There are three specific clues the
officer is looking for: (1) as the eye moves from side
to side, does it move smoothly, or does it jerk
noticeably?; (2) when the eye moves as far to the side
as possible and is kept in that position for several
seconds, does it jerk distinctly?; (3) as the eye moves
towards the periphery, does it start to jerk prior to a
45 degree angle?
The more impaired the person is, the more likely it is
that the officer will observe one or more of the above
clues.
The maximum number of clues in each eye is three, with
the total number of clues possible being six (3 for each
eye).
Research has indicated that if four or more clues are
evident, it is likely that the person's blood alcohol
content is above a .10. With 4 or more clues
present, the HGN test is 77% accurate.
Defenses: nystagmus can be caused by
factors other than alcohol or drug impairment.
Optokinetic nystagmus occurs when the eyes fixate on an
object that suddenly moves out of sigh, or when the eyes
watch sharply contrasting moving images. Examples
are strobe lights, rotating lights, or rapidly moving
traffic in close proximity.
Nystagmus can also naturally occur
from pathological disorders such as brain damage or
diseases of the inner ear. In order to determine
whether nystagmus is attributable to a pathological
disorder, the officer should determine pupil size,
resting nystagmus and tracking ability.
Specifically, if the pupils are not equal size, if the
eyes bounce looking straight ahead, and if the eyes do
not track together, a pathological condition may be
present.
Maximum deviation- when an officer
checks for nystagmus at maximum deviation (i.e. looking
to the extreme periphery of vision) there is some
natural nystagmus. However, the nystagmus is not
pronounced, nor sustained. When a person is
impaired, the nystagmus is pronouced at maximum
deviation and is sustained for more than 4 seconds.
If the officer does not hold the stimulus at maximum
deviation for more than 4 seconds, the nystagmus
observed could be naturally occurring nystagmus.
With respects to the onset of
nystagmus prior to 45 degrees, if the officer moves the
stimulus too fast, he will miss the angle at which he
observes nystagmus.
Nystagmus can be caused from
substances other than alcohol. Specifically, some
seizure medications and some other prescribed drugs can
cause nystagmus.
|
|
|
|
The 9 step walk and turn test is
a divided attention test. The person
submitting to the test must pay attention to the
instruction phase of the test and then apply the
instructions to the walking phase of the test.
Instruction phase: in the
instruction phase, suspects are to stand with their
feet in the heel to toe position, keep their arms at
their sides, and listen to the instructions.
The instruction phase divides the subject's
attention between a balancing task, and hearing and
comprehending instructions.
Specifically, the officer is to give the following
instructions:
(1) "place your left foot on the line"
(demonstrate);
(2) "place your right foot on the line ahead of the
left foot, with the heel of the right foot against
the toe of your left foot." (demonstrate);
(3) "place your arms down at your sides"
(demonstrate);
(4) "maintain this position until I have completed
the instructions. Do not start to walk until
told to do so."
(5) "do you understand the instructions so far?"
(ensure understanding)
(6) "when I tell you to start, take nine heel to toe
steps, turn, and take nine heel to toe steps back"
(demonstrate 3 heel to toe steps);
(7) "when you turn, keep the front foot on the line,
and turn by taking a series of small steps with the
other foot, like this". (demonstrate)
(8) while you are walking, keep your arms at your
sides, watch your feet at all times, and count your
steps out loud"
(9) "once you start walking, don't stop until you
have completed the test."
(10) "do you understand the instructions?" (make
sure suspect understands)
(11) "begin, and count your first step from the heel
to toe position as one."
Walking phase: the subject takes
nine heel to toe steps, turns in a prescribed
manner, and takes nine heel to toe steps back, while
counting out loud, while watching their feet.
During the turn, the suspect keeps their front foot
on the line, and makes a pivot turn with several
small steps with the other foot. The walking
test divides a person's attention between a
balancing task, small muscle control (counting out
loud) and a short term memory task (recalling the
number of steps and the turning instructions.
There are eight possible clues:
(1) can't balance during instruction; (2) starting
to walk too soon; (3) stopping while walking; (4)
fails to touch heel to toe; (5) steps off line; (6)
uses arms for balance; (7) loses balance on turn or
turns incorrectly; (8) takes the wrong number of
steps.
Research indicates that if a
suspect exhibits two or more clues, or cannot
complete the test, the suspect's BAC is likely to be
above .10. When 2 or more clues are present,
the test is accurate 68% of the time.
Defenses: whether
a suspect was given proper instructions is the
initial analysis in the defense to a DUI. If
instructions are not properly given, then the
failure to follow the instructions cannot be
considered to be a clue by the officer.
Oftentimes, an officer will treat the use of arms
for balance or swaying during the instruction phase
of the 9 step walk and turn as a clue, but in fact,
it is not, so long as the suspect does not break
heel to toe during the instruction phase.
In addition, walking slowly is not a clue.
Only when the suspect pauses for several seconds
should a clue be noted.
Heel to toe does not actually mean heel to toe with
no gap. The NHTSA manual recognizes a
tolerance of 1/2 inch between the heel and toe.
Steps off the line cannot be partial steps off the
line, be it real or imaginary. In order for a
clue to be noted, the step must be entirely off the
line.
Raising arms for balance is another frequently noted
clue. However, the suspect must raise his/her
arms more than 6 inches to constitute a clue.
The test conditions frequently create a defense.
The test requires a designated straight line and
conducted on a reasonably hard, dry, hard, level,
nonslippery surface.
Suspects over 65 years of age, persons with back,
leg or inner ear problems should not perform the
test.
In addition, persons wearing heels in excess of 2
inches should be given the opportunity to remove
their shoes when performing the test.
|
|
|
|
The one leg stand is also a
divided attention test. The suspect's
attention is divided between the instruction phase
and the balance and counting phase.
Instruction phase: the suspect must stand with feet
together, keep their arms at their sides, and listen
to instructions. The suspect's attention is
divided between a balancing task and listening to
and comprehending instructions.
Instruction phase: the officer is to give the
following instructions:
(1) "stand with your feet together and your arms
down at the sides, like this." (demonstrate).
(2) "do not start to perform the test until I tell
you to do so."
(3) "do you understand the instructions so far?"
(4) "when I tell you to start, raise one leg, either
leg, with the foot approximately 6 inches above the
ground, keeping your raised foot parallel to the
ground (demonstrate)
(5) "you must keep both legs straight, arms at your
side".
(6) "while holding that position, count out loud in
the following manner....one thousand and one, one
thousand and two, one thousand and three, until told
to stop." (demonstrate).
(7) "keep your arms at your sides at all times and
keep watching the raised foot."
(8) "do you understand?" (ensures suspect
understands test).
(9) "go ahead and perform the test." (officer should
time the 30 seconds. The test should be
discontinued after 30 seconds.)
Balancing phase: the subject must raise one leg,
either leg, with the foot approximately 6 inches off
the ground, keeping the raise foot parallel to the
ground. While looking at the elevated foot,
the suspect must count out loud in the following
manner: "one thousand and one, one thousand and two"
and so one until told to stop.
The timing of the test is 30 seconds. The
significance of 30 seconds is that the research
shows that many impaired subjects are able to stand
on one leg for up to 25 seconds, but that few can do
so for 30 seconds.
There are 4 clues the officer is looking for: (1)
swaying while balancing; (2) using arms to balance;
(3) hopping; (4) putting foot down while counting.
Research indicates that when the
suspect produces two or more clues or is unable to
complete the test, it is likely that the BAC is
above .10. When two or more clues are
observed, the test is accurate 65% of the time.
Defenses: the test requires a
reasonably dry, hard, level, and non slippery
surface. If a person counts slowly, the
officer should terminate the test after the passage
of 30 seconds, regardless of what number the suspect
is counting. Persons over the age of 65,
persons with back, leg or inner ear problems should
not perform the test. Individuals wearing
heels more than 2 inches should be given the
opportunity to remove their shoes.
|
|
|
|