Edward Stone
Attorney at Law
435.658.3366

LEGALITY OF STOP

Please select from below for applicable Utah statutes and explanations:

* This is by no means intended to be a complete description of rights in the State of Utah. This page is intended to give a litigant an idea of the analysis of an initial stop. A complete description of rights can be found in the Utah Code and the Utah Rules. Do not rely on this page alone for guidance; consult with an attorney. This page does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Please contact Edward Stone for more information.

In order to initiate a traffic stop, a police officer either has to have "reasonable suspicion" that either an illegal act has been committed or that a traffic law has been broken.  This is an important distinction from that of probable cause.  Reasonable suspicion can be based on information from other drivers communicated through dispatch, or other information that does not include an officer actually witnessing the traffic violation.  Most recently, the Utah Supreme Court stated that reasonable suspicion is, reasonable suspicion requires a particularized and objective basis, supported by specific and articulable facts. Courts should evaluate these facts in their totality, rather than looking at each fact in isolation. Although the standard requires more than an inchoate and unparticularized ... hunch, it does not require an officer to rule out innocent conduct or establish the likelihood of criminal conduct to the same degree as required for probable cause.  In other words, an officer can initiate a traffic stop if he/she has a particular theory of what has happened and the theory is based on specific fact.

Nevertheless, the detention following a routine traffic stop is generally limited to examining the driver's license and vehicle registration, conducting a computer check, and issuing a citation. See, e.g., State v. Robinson, 797 P.2d 431, 435 (Utah Ct.App.1990). Unsupported by further probable cause or reasonable suspicion, inquiries by the officer to investigate suspicions unrelated to the traffic offense unconstitutionally extend the detention beyond the scope of the circumstances that rendered it permissible


If a traffic violation is committed in a law enforcement officer's presence, the officer has not only reasonable suspicion but probable cause to stop the vehicle.